Transformer Proximity Effect Calculator
Model high-frequency eddy current winding losses using Dowell's equation, evaluate layer porosity factors, and quantify interleaving copper loss reduction.
Dowell AC Resistance & Loss Results
Power Loss & Interleaving Comparison
Recommended Tools & Equipment
Tested hardware and components for high reliability
Understanding High-Frequency Proximity Effect in Transformers
At high switching frequencies (100 kHz to 2 MHz) in switch-mode power supplies (flyback, LLC, phase-shifted full-bridge), standard DC copper resistance calculations severely underestimate winding losses. While the skin effect drives current toward the surface of an isolated conductor, the proximity effect—induced by the magnetic field generated by adjacent conductor turns and layers—forces current into narrow filaments, causing AC resistance to multiply by $5\times$ to $50\times$.
Dowell's 1D Analytical Formulation
P.L. Dowell (1966) derived the classical closed-form 1D eddy-current equation for multi-layer windings. The AC-to-DC resistance factor $F_R = R_{ac} / R_{dc}$ is formulated as:
Where:
- $\xi = \frac{h}{\delta} \sqrt{\eta}$: Normalized conductor thickness relative to skin depth $\delta$ scaled by layer porosity $\eta$.
- $m$: Number of layers in a winding portion where magnetomotive force (MMF) builds up continuously.
- $\delta = \sqrt{\frac{\rho}{\pi f \mu_0}}$: Skin depth of annealed copper at operating temperature $T$.
- $\eta = \frac{N_l \cdot d_w}{b_w}$: Porosity factor representing the copper fill width along the bobbin traverse $b_w$. For round wire, Dowell replaces round conductors with equivalent square foils of thickness $h = d_w \sqrt{\pi / 4} \approx 0.8862 d_w$.
The Dominance of the $m^2$ Factor
Notice that the proximity term scales with $(m^2 - 1)$. In a 4-layer primary winding ($m = 4$), the term $(4^2 - 1) = 15$ multiplies the proximity loss. If the winding is interleaved in a sandwich configuration (Primary - Secondary - Primary, or P-S-P), the MMF resets to zero at the boundary, halving $m$ from 4 to 2. This reduces $(m^2 - 1)$ from 15 down to 3—a $5\times$ reduction in proximity-induced eddy losses!
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does proximity effect cause much more loss than skin effect in transformers?
The skin effect creates an internal eddy current within each isolated wire, which grows modestly with wire diameter. However, the proximity effect is caused by the external transverse magnetic field created by ALL other turns in the winding window. Because Ampere's law causes the MMF to build up linearly across successive layers, the external H-field reaches enormous peak magnitudes at the primary-to-secondary interface, driving intense eddy currents across entire conductor cross-sections.
When should I switch from solid magnet wire to Litz wire or copper foil?
When conductor diameter d exceeds 2 times the skin depth (d > 2δ) and the layer count m ≥ 2, solid wire becomes extremely lossy (F_R > 3). If using foil, keep foil thickness h near δ for single-layer windings. For multi-layer windings, multi-strand Litz wire with strand diameters smaller than δ (typically AWG 38 or AWG 40 for 100-300 kHz) eliminates the layer MMF proximity penalty.
How does Dowell's model handle round wire vs flat foil?
Dowell's original paper converts round wires of diameter d into equivalent rectangular sheets with the same cross-sectional area: h = d · √(π/4) ≈ 0.886 d. The layer porosity factor η accounts for the air gap between adjacent round turns along the bobbin window width b_w.